BrainFinch
Articles

The Simon effect explained, with a game to feel it

The Simon effect is the finding that people respond faster when a stimulus appears on the same side as the response it calls for, and slower when it appears on the other side. The side is irrelevant to the task and still changes how quickly they answer. It is named after J. Richard Simon, who reported it in the 1960s.

The game above, Simon Space, puts an arrow on the left or right of the screen and asks only which way it points.

What is the Simon effect?

The Simon effect is a spatial match effect between a stimulus and a response. Dolk and colleagues (2011) describe it in one line: responses are typically faster when they spatially correspond to the stimulus that signals them.

A trial in a typical Simon task has three parts:

  1. A stimulus appears on the left or the right.
  2. Some feature of it other than its position tells you which response to make. In many versions that feature is not spatial at all, such as a color.
  3. You respond with a left or right key.

When the stimulus and the correct key are on the same side, the trial is called compatible or corresponding. When they are on opposite sides it is incompatible. The Simon effect is the difference in speed and accuracy between the two.

Psychologists file it under stimulus-response compatibility. Proctor’s 2011 review in Acta Psychologica calls the Simon effect a correspondence effect and goes through how the task has been used to study human information processing.

What did Simon and Rudell find in 1967?

Simon and Rudell found that people were slower to respond to a spoken word when it arrived in the ear on the opposite side to the response it asked for.

Their paper, “Auditory S-R compatibility: the effect of an irrelevant cue on information processing”, appeared in the Journal of Applied Psychology in 1967. The task was done by ear. People heard the word “left” or the word “right”, and it was played at random to the left ear or the right ear. They were to respond according to what the word said. Which ear it arrived in was not part of the instruction.

The ear affected the answer anyway. Reaction times were clearly longer when the word and the ear disagreed, for example the word “right” heard in the left ear.

This was not the first sign of the effect. Simon and Wolf had published a study in Ergonomics in 1963 that used lights on a panel that could be rotated, and the PsyToolkit task library dates Simon’s first description of the effect to that paper. The 1967 study is the one usually cited because the irrelevant feature in it, the ear, was so plainly unrelated to the instruction.

Why does the position of a stimulus affect the response?

Simon’s own explanation was that people have an automatic tendency to react toward the source of a stimulus. A sound in the left ear or a shape on the left of a screen favors a response on the left before the instructed feature has been dealt with.

Most explanations place the conflict at the point where the response is chosen. Two candidate responses are ready, one prompted by where the stimulus is and one by what the instructions say, and when they differ the wrong one has to lose.

That makes the Simon effect a relative of two other interference effects. In the Stroop task the meaning of a word gets in the way of naming its ink color, which we cover in the Stroop effect explained. In the flanker task the items beside a target get in the way.

How does Simon Space work?

An arrow tile appears against the left or right edge of the board, pointing left or right. You swipe in the direction the arrow points, or tap one of the two arrow buttons. A round lasts 25 seconds and each correct answer is one point.

There is no deadline on a single arrow. A correct answer brings the next arrow at once. A wrong answer shakes the tile and locks the board for 800 milliseconds.

Our version differs from the classic task in one way. In many laboratory versions the feature you respond to is not spatial, such as a color that has been assigned to a key. In Simon Space the feature you respond to is the direction of an arrow, which is spatial too. The game keeps what the task is known for, a position that is irrelevant and still pulls at the answer, and drops the need to learn a color rule first.

How often does the arrow point away from its side?

It starts at 30 percent of arrows and rises to 80 percent. The game’s code calls a trial a clash when the arrow points away from the side it sits on, and it sets the chance of a clash from a step number.

The step is your level plus one for every five arrows answered in the round, right or wrong. Your level starts at 0, goes up after two rounds in a row with at least 80 percent accuracy, and comes down after a round under 50 percent.

We read the formula from the generator and then checked it by generating 20,000 arrows at each step with a short program. The measured shares were within half a percentage point of the formula at every step.

Step Arrows that point away from their side Where the tile sits
0 30% Middle height
1 36% Middle height
2 42% Middle height
3 48% Top, middle or bottom
4 54% Top, middle or bottom
5 60% Top, middle or bottom
6 66% Top, middle or bottom
7 72% Top, middle or bottom
8 78% Top, middle or bottom
9 and up 80% Top, middle or bottom

From step 4 onward, clashes are the majority. A player at level 0 gets there after 20 answered arrows. By step 9, which takes 45 answered arrows from level 0, four arrows in five point away from their side.

From step 3 the tile also moves up and down. It picks the top, middle or bottom of the board with equal chance, so it is away from the middle on two arrows in three. The height has no bearing on the answer. It is there so that the tile cannot be watched from two fixed spots.

Simon and Rudell sent each word to one ear or the other at random. Our game does not keep the two cases balanced. The steady rise in clashes is a design choice that stops a 25 second round from settling into a rhythm.

What does that mean for how you play?

The mechanics suggest a few habits.

  1. Read the arrowhead. The tile’s side tells you nothing certain at any step.
  2. Do not bet on the side early. At step 0 an arrow points toward its own side 70 percent of the time, so a player who answers by side alone is wrong on 30 percent of arrows and pays 800 milliseconds for each.
  3. Do not bet against the side late either. At the cap, answering the opposite of the side is wrong on one arrow in five. In a 25 second round, five wrong answers cost four seconds of locked board.
  4. Expect the crossover. For a player at level 0 the usual case flips from matching to clashing at the twentieth arrow, and a habit built in the first few seconds stops paying at that point.
  5. Let your eyes go to the tile each time once it starts moving up and down. The arrow is large, between 88 and 132 points across depending on your screen, and can be read at a glance once you are looking at it.

What does a Simon Space score mean?

Your score is the number of arrows you answered correctly in 25 seconds. It is a game score. In research, the Simon effect is measured as a difference between two kinds of trial under controlled timing, and a single round on a phone does not produce that measure or say anything about a person’s health or ability.

People do get quicker at this game with practice. That is practice at the game, and broad transfer from games like it to other skills is not established. We set out the evidence in what the research shows about brain training games.

For a different irrelevant signal, try Arrow Focus, where arrows beside the target point the wrong way, or Color Clash, where a word names the wrong color. Opposite Day turns the rule around and asks you to swipe against the arrow.

Common questions

What is the Simon effect?

It is the finding that people respond faster and more accurately when a stimulus appears on the same side as the response it calls for, even when the side of the stimulus has nothing to do with the task.

Who discovered the Simon effect?

It is named after J. Richard Simon. The study most often cited is Simon and Rudell (1967) in the Journal of Applied Psychology, where people heard the words left and right in one ear or the other. Simon and Wolf had reported a related result with lights in 1963.

What is the difference between the Simon effect and the Stroop effect?

Both come from a feature you are told to ignore. In the Stroop task the ignored feature is the meaning of a word and it competes with naming the ink color. In the Simon task the ignored feature is where the stimulus is, and it competes with a left or right response.

Sources

  1. Simon, J. R., & Rudell, A. P. (1967). Auditory S-R compatibility: the effect of an irrelevant cue on information processing. Journal of Applied Psychology, 51(3), 300-304.
  2. Wikipedia: Simon effect
  3. PsyToolkit experiment library: Simon task
  4. Dolk, T., Hommel, B., Colzato, L. S., Schütz-Bosbach, S., Prinz, W., & Liepelt, R. (2011). How social is the social Simon effect? Frontiers in Psychology, 2, 84.
  5. Proctor, R. W. (2011). Playing the Simon game: use of the Simon task for investigating human information processing. Acta Psychologica, 136(2), 182-188.

Games in this article

Take all 62 games with you

The BrainFinch app plays offline, keeps your streak and reminds you when the daily challenge is ready.

Get it on Google Play