BrainFinch
Articles

Mental rotation test explained, from 1971 to Rotate It

A mental rotation test shows pictures of an object from different angles and asks which ones are the same object. In the first experiment of this kind, Shepard and Metzler (1971) found that the time people took to answer rose in a straight line with the angle between the two views.

The game above is Rotate It, our four-choice version. This page covers the 1971 study, then what our code does when it builds a figure and its three wrong answers.

What is a mental rotation test?

It is a task where you judge if two drawings show one object in two positions. The object is usually built from small cubes joined face to face, and it is drawn so that you see it in depth.

In the laboratory version each trial is a pair, and the answer is “same” or “different”. Vandenberg and Kuse (1978) turned the idea into a paper test called the Mental Rotations Test, which had 20 items.

What did Shepard and Metzler find in 1971?

They found that response time grew in step with the angle between the two drawings. The paper, “Mental Rotation of Three-Dimensional Objects”, ran in Science on 19 February 1971.

The design, as the paper describes it:

  • Eight adults each judged 1,600 pairs of line drawings.
  • Every object was ten cubes joined into an arm with exactly three right-angle bends.
  • The two drawings in a pair differed by 0 to 180 degrees, in steps of 20 degrees.
  • Half the pairs showed the same object. In the other half one object was the mirror image of the other.
  • People pulled one lever for “same” and another for “different”.

For “same” pairs the average time went from about 1 second at 0 degrees to between 4 and 6 seconds at 180 degrees, depending on the person. The line was straight for every one of the eight people. Only 3.2 percent of the answers were wrong.

The same data gave two more results. Turning a drawing flat on the page took no less time than turning the object in depth. And the slope of the line worked out to roughly 60 degrees per second for these objects, which the authors read as people turning a mental picture at a steady rate.

Why were the wrong pairs mirror images?

Mirror images were chosen so that nobody could answer from a single feature. A mirrored object has the same number of cubes, the same arm lengths and the same number of bends. The only difference is which way the bends turn.

Shepard and Metzler say this in the paper: the mirror pairs were meant to stop people from finding a distinctive feature on one object and deciding without rotating anything.

How does Rotate It draw and turn its figures?

Rotate It grows each figure one cube at a time inside a box three cubes wide, deep and tall, then shows it from one fixed viewpoint. Each cube is drawn with three flat tones for its top, left and right faces.

The figure is turned with the 24 rotations of a cube, which are quarter turns about its three axes and their combinations. So the answer is never tilted by 20 or 40 degrees as in the 1971 drawings. It is the same object standing on a different face.

Our code rejects a pose unless every cube shows at least two of the six half faces a viewer could see, so no cube is hidden behind the others. It also checks pictures against each other:

  • The correct option never looks identical to the figure at the top. In 22,000 puzzles we generated to test this, it never did.
  • No wrong option can look like any of the 24 views of the top figure.
  • All four options are drawn at one scale, so size is no clue.

What are the wrong options in Rotate It?

Each wrong option is a different object with the same number of cubes. The code makes them in two ways.

The first is to lift one cube off the figure and attach it somewhere else, keeping the figure in one piece. The result usually has an arm that is one cube shorter or longer than the original.

The second is the mirror image, as in the 1971 study. A mirror image only counts as a different object when the figure is chiral, meaning no rotation turns it into its own reflection. From step 3 the game only uses chiral figures, so a mirror image is always among the options.

From step 6 a moved-cube figure is itself shown mirrored half the time. Without this, a player could spot the one mirrored option and rule it out without checking the rest.

How does Rotate It change by level?

The figure grows from four cubes to seven, and mirror images go from rare to guaranteed. A round starts at the step the game has saved for you, which is 0 on a first round, and the step goes up by one after every three figures. The round lasts 45 seconds.

We read these values from the game’s generator and measured the mirror column by generating 2,000 puzzles at each step.

Step Cubes Puzzles with a mirror image among the wrong options Other wrong options
0 to 1 4 13.6 percent, by chance only One cube moved
2 5 42.9 percent, whenever the figure is chiral One cube moved
3 to 4 5 100 percent One cube moved
5 6 100 percent One cube moved
6 to 8 6 100 percent One cube moved, mirrored half the time
9 and up 7 100 percent One cube moved, mirrored half the time

At steps 0 and 1 the code never adds a mirror image on purpose. The 13.6 percent comes from moved-cube figures that happen to equal the reflection.

How many different figures can Rotate It show?

At seven cubes there are 485 different objects that fit the box, and 418 of them are chiral. We counted these with a short program that builds every figure inside a 3 by 3 by 3 box and groups together the ones that are rotations of each other.

Cubes Different objects Chiral objects Mirror pairs
4 7 2 1
5 25 12 6
6 111 82 41
7 485 418 209

Mirror images count as separate objects in this table. Without the box there are 8 four-cube figures counted this way, and the one we lose is the straight bar of four, which is too long to fit.

The share of chiral figures rises from 2 in 7 to 418 in 485. That is why the game can demand a chiral figure at five cubes and up without running short.

How do you tell a rotation from a mirror image?

Walk along the figure from one end and name each bend. A rotation keeps the order and direction of the bends, and a mirror image flips the direction of one kind of bend.

A method that works in the game:

  1. Count the cubes in each straight arm of the top figure. An option with a different count is a moved-cube figure, so drop it.
  2. Pick the longest arm and find it in each remaining option.
  3. From the end of that arm, note which way the next arm leaves: toward you, away, left, right, up or down.
  4. Compare the following bend relative to the first. If it turns the opposite way, the option is the mirror image.

Step 1 is fast and clears most options at the low steps. A mirror image always passes it, so from step 3 you need steps 2 to 4 on every puzzle.

Does a Rotate It score mean anything outside the game?

No. A score counts how many figures you matched in 45 seconds, and it says nothing about your abilities.

People do get quicker at mental rotation tasks they practice. Whether that practice carries over to other tasks is a separate question, and the research on brain training has not established broad transfer.

If you like this kind of puzzle, Mirror Match asks for the reflection of a flat block shape, Cube Net asks which flat net folds into a cube, and Fold It is a fold-and-punch puzzle that we describe in our guide to paper folding puzzles.

Common questions

What is a mental rotation test?

It is a task that shows two or more pictures of an object and asks which ones show the same object turned to a different angle. The wrong pictures usually show a mirror image or a slightly different object.

What did Shepard and Metzler find in 1971?

The time people needed to confirm that two drawings showed the same object rose in a straight line with the angle between the two views, from about 1 second at 0 degrees to between 4 and 6 seconds at 180 degrees.

Why are mirror images used as the wrong answers?

A mirror image has the same cube counts, arm lengths and bends as the original, so no single feature gives it away. Shepard and Metzler chose mirror pairs for that reason.

How many cubes do the figures in Rotate It have?

Four at the start, then five, six and seven as the difficulty step rises. Every figure fits inside a box three cubes wide on each side.

Sources

  1. Shepard, R. N., & Metzler, J. (1971). Mental rotation of three-dimensional objects. Science, 171(3972), 701-703.
  2. Thomas, N. J. T. Mental rotation. Supplement to Mental Imagery, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
  3. Mental rotation. Wikipedia.
  4. Polycube. Wikipedia.

Games in this article

Take all 62 games with you

The BrainFinch app plays offline, keeps your streak and reminds you when the daily challenge is ready.

Get it on Google Play