BrainFinch
Articles

Working memory vs short term memory: what is the difference?

Short term memory is holding a small amount of information for a few seconds. Working memory is holding it while you do something with it, such as reordering it, updating it or adding to it. Researchers use the two terms for holding versus holding plus manipulating, although tests of the two overlap heavily.

The game above, Reverse Sequence, sits on the manipulating side: you watch tiles light up and tap them back last to first.

What is short term memory?

Short term memory is the ability to keep a little information available for a short time without changing it. The standard example is digit span: a series of digits is presented and repeated back straight away.

Atkinson and Shiffrin’s 1968 model drew memory as a series of boxes, with a short term store ahead of a long term one. In that picture the short term store is a single holding place.

How much it holds is small. Cowan (2008) lists the two properties usually given to short term memory: it fades with time, and it is limited to a few chunks.

What is the Baddeley and Hitch model of working memory?

It is a model, proposed by Alan Baddeley and Graham Hitch in 1974, that replaced the single short term store with a system of three parts.

  1. The phonological loop holds verbal material, such as a phone number you repeat to yourself.
  2. The visuospatial sketchpad holds what things look like and where they are.
  3. The central executive supervises the other two and controls the flow of information. It is not a store itself.

Part of the evidence was that people can do two tasks at once nearly as well as each alone when one task is verbal and the other visual.

In 2000 Baddeley added a fourth part, the episodic buffer, which ties together information from the two stores and from long term memory into one episode.

The term itself is older. Cowan (2008) traces “working memory” to Miller, Galanter and Pribram in 1960, who used it for memory as it is used to plan and carry out behavior.

What is the difference between holding and manipulating?

Holding means the answer is what you were shown. Manipulating means you have to change what you were shown before you can answer.

Aben, Stapert and Blokland (2012) put the distinction as maintenance versus maintenance plus manipulation, and describe the two kinds of test that go with it. A simple span task asks you to keep a set of items and give them back. A complex span task adds a demanding second job to a simple span task, such as solving arithmetic between the items.

Backward span sits on the border. The same review says there is no consensus about what it involves: some researchers class it with simple span, and others count the reordering as an extra task. Kessels and colleagues (2008) found that backward digit span was harder than forward digit span, while tapping a sequence of positions backward was no harder than tapping it forward.

Which BrainFinch games ask you to hold, and which to manipulate?

Digit Flash, Sequence Tap and Flash Grid ask you to hold. Reverse Sequence, N-Back, Running Total and Double Duty ask you to change or protect what you hold while doing something else. We built the table from each game’s code, and the starting figures are for a new player at level 0.

Game What you are shown What you must do before answering Holding or manipulating
Digit Flash A 3 digit number for 1.4 seconds Nothing. Type it as shown Holding
Sequence Tap 3 tiles lighting 0.62 seconds apart Nothing. Tap them in the same order Holding
Flash Grid 3 lit squares on a 3 by 3 grid for 1.7 seconds Nothing. Tap them in any order Holding
Reverse Sequence 2 tiles lighting 0.68 seconds apart Reverse the order, then tap last to first Manipulating (reordering)
N-Back A stream of shapes, one every 1.6 seconds Compare each shape with the one N steps back, then drop the oldest and add the newest Manipulating (updating)
Running Total A start number, then 3 plus or minus steps, each for 1.5 seconds Add or subtract each step as it appears and keep only the new total Manipulating (updating by arithmetic)
Double Duty A row of 2 shapes for 1.6 seconds, then 2 sums Judge each sum true or false while keeping the row, then rebuild the row in order Holding plus a second task (complex span)

Some details from the code show where the load comes from.

Reverse Sequence starts one tile shorter than Sequence Tap, at two tiles, and lights each tile 60 milliseconds slower. It tops out at nine tiles where Sequence Tap goes to ten. The comment in the code gives the reason: “Backwards is harder”.

N-Back never lets the list settle. Three shapes in every ten are matches, and N is 1 at levels 0 and 1, 2 at levels 2 to 5, and 3 from level 6. The article on the n-back game walks through an example.

Running Total grows from three steps to seven, and the numbers come faster, from 1.5 seconds each down to 0.65. The chain is never shown again, so the only thing worth holding is the current total.

Double Duty is our complex span task. The shapes score only if you judged more than half of the sums correctly, which stops a player from ignoring the sums to protect the row. The row grows from two shapes to four, and the sums from two to three. A false sum is always off by one or two.

Are working memory and short term memory really separate?

By definition they are separate, and in test scores the line is much harder to find. Aben and colleagues (2012) reviewed the correlational studies and concluded that they have not separated the two consistently, with evidence for a large or even complete overlap.

Part of the trouble is that “working memory” has more than one meaning. Cowan (2008) counts three: short term memory applied to cognitive tasks, a multi-component system that holds and manipulates information, and the use of attention to manage short term memory.

The holding versus manipulating distinction describes tasks well and describes people less well. You can say with confidence that Reverse Sequence asks for something Sequence Tap does not. It is much harder to show that the two games draw on separate systems in the head.

Does practicing a working memory game carry over to other tasks?

The evidence says mostly no. Melby-Lervåg and Hulme (2013) combined 23 studies of working memory training and found reliable short-term gains on working memory tasks, with no convincing evidence that the gains spread to other skills such as verbal ability or arithmetic.

People do get better at the game they practice. If you play Reverse Sequence every day, expect your Reverse Sequence score to rise. Our article on what brain training research shows covers the wider evidence.

A simple way to feel the difference this article describes is to play Sequence Tap and then Reverse Sequence back to back. The tiles, the grid and the 40 second round are the same. The only thing that changes is what you have to do with the sequence before you tap.

Common questions

What is the difference between working memory and short term memory?

Short term memory is holding a small amount of information for a few seconds. Working memory is holding it while also doing something with it, such as reordering it or updating it.

Is digit span a working memory test?

Forward digit span is usually classed as a short term memory task, because you repeat the digits as given. Researchers disagree about backward digit span, according to Aben, Stapert and Blokland (2012).

Who proposed the working memory model?

Alan Baddeley and Graham Hitch proposed a three-component model of working memory in 1974. Baddeley added a fourth component, the episodic buffer, in 2000.

Are working memory and short term memory the same thing?

They are defined differently, but tests of the two overlap heavily. Aben and colleagues (2012) concluded that correlational studies have not separated them consistently.

Sources

  1. Baddeley, A. (2000). The episodic buffer: a new component of working memory? Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 4(11), 417-423.
  2. Cowan, N. (2008). What are the differences between long-term, short-term, and working memory? Progress in Brain Research, 169, 323-338.
  3. Aben, B., Stapert, S., & Blokland, A. (2012). About the distinction between working memory and short-term memory. Frontiers in Psychology, 3, 301.
  4. Kessels, R. P., van den Berg, E., Ruis, C., & Brands, A. M. (2008). The backward span of the Corsi Block-Tapping Task and its association with the WAIS-III Digit Span. Assessment, 15(4), 426-434.
  5. Melby-Lervåg, M., & Hulme, C. (2013). Is working memory training effective? A meta-analytic review. Developmental Psychology, 49(2), 270-291.
  6. Baddeley's model of working memory. Wikipedia (used for the names of the model's components).

Games in this article

Take all 62 games with you

The BrainFinch app plays offline, keeps your streak and reminds you when the daily challenge is ready.

Get it on Google Play