How to solve matrix reasoning puzzles: rules and checklist
To solve a matrix reasoning puzzle, take one feature at a time, such as shape, number, shading or rotation. Find the rule that feature follows along the rows and columns, then apply every rule to the empty cell. Most 3 by 3 puzzles are built from four kinds of rule: constant, progression, distribution of three, and addition.
The game above is Missing Shape, our timed version of matrix reasoning puzzles, with the gap always in the bottom right corner.
What is a matrix reasoning puzzle?
It is a grid of figures with one cell left empty and a row of options to fill it. The figures change in a regular way as you move across and down, and the correct option is the one figure that keeps every pattern going.
Nothing in the puzzle is written in words. The rules have to be read off the pictures, which is why the first job is deciding what the features are.
What rule types do 3 by 3 matrix puzzles use?
A small set of rules covers most puzzles of this kind. Carpenter, Just and Shell (1990) analyzed how people solve the items of Raven’s matrix test and proposed a list of rule types. Little, Lewandowsky and Craig (2014) summarize that list as a constant rule, a pairwise progression rule, a distribution of three rule, a distribution of two rule, and addition and subtraction rules.
| Rule | What you see across a row | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Constant in a row | The feature does not change | All three figures are circles |
| Progression | The feature steps by the same amount | 1 dot, 2 dots, 3 dots |
| Distribution of three | Three values, each once per row, in varying order | Circle, square, triangle, then square, triangle, circle |
| Addition or overlay | The third figure combines the first two | A vertical line and a horizontal line make a cross |
| Subtraction or distribution of two | Parts shared by the first two figures drop out of the third | Two figures share a dot, and the third has none |
A single puzzle usually runs several rules at once, each on its own feature. Shape might follow distribution of three while the count follows a progression. Carpenter, Just and Shell’s models pointed to the number of rules in an item and their types as what makes it hard.
Where do matrix puzzles come from?
The best known set is Raven’s Progressive Matrices. John C. Raven first published it in the United Kingdom in 1938. The standard form has 60 multiple-choice items in five sets of 12, listed in order of increasing difficulty. Each item gives six to eight options for the missing piece.
Puzzle books and games use the same format with their own figures. Ours are generated by code each round, so no item is taken from any published test.
What is a checklist for solving one?
Go feature by feature and never try to see the whole figure at once.
- List the features that differ anywhere in the grid. Typical ones are shape, how many, shading, size and which way the figure points.
- Take the first feature and read it along the top row. Decide if it is constant, stepping in order, or three different values.
- Check the second row. If it repeats the top row’s pattern, you have the rule. If the same three values come in a different order, it is distribution of three.
- If rows show nothing, read down the columns. Some rules run downward.
- Write down what that feature must be in the empty cell.
- Repeat for each remaining feature.
- Put the answers together and look for that exact figure in the options.
- If two options seem to fit, you missed a feature. Compare those two options with each other and see what differs.
Step 8 is useful because of how wrong options are made. In Missing Shape the wrong tiles are near misses first: figures that differ from the answer in one changing feature, then figures that differ in two.
How does a worked example go?
Here is a grid that our generator produced at step 6, written out in words.
| Column 1 | Column 2 | Column 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Row 1 | 1 dotted diamond | 3 hollow diamonds | 2 solid diamonds |
| Row 2 | 3 hollow crosses | 2 solid crosses | 1 dotted cross |
| Row 3 | 2 solid stars | 1 dotted star | empty |
Shape first. Row 1 is all diamonds, row 2 all crosses, row 3 all stars. Shape is constant in a row, so the gap holds stars.
Count next. Each row has 1, 2 and 3 in a different order, and so does each column. Row 3 already has 2 and 1, so the gap needs 3.
Fill last. Each row has dotted, hollow and solid once. Row 3 has solid and dotted, so the gap is hollow.
The answer is 3 hollow stars. The six options in that puzzle were 3 hollow crosses, 1 hollow star, 3 solid stars, 2 hollow stars, 3 hollow stars and 3 dotted stars. Each of the five wrong ones differs from the answer in a single feature.
Which rule types does Missing Shape use at each level?
Missing Shape uses four rules, and each feature of the figures gets one of them. The features are shape, count (1 to 3 copies), fill (solid, hollow or dotted) and rotation in quarter turns.
- Same everywhere: the feature never changes.
- Same along each row: it differs from row to row. This is the constant in a row rule.
- Same down each column: reading across a row, you see three values in a fixed order. For count and rotation the values step in order, so this reads as a progression.
- One of each: every row and every column contains each of the three values once. This is distribution of three.
The game has no addition, overlay or subtraction rules.
We read the table below from the game’s generator.
| Step | Features that change | Of those, one of each rules | Features in play | Answer tiles | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 1 | 0 | Shape, count, fill | 4 | 1 |
| 1 to 2 | 2 | 0 | Shape, count, fill | 4 | 1 |
| 3 | 2 | 1 | Shape, count, fill | 4 | 1 |
| 4 to 5 | 2 | 1 | Shape, count, fill, rotation | 6 | 1 |
| 6 to 8 | 3 | 2 | Shape, count, fill, rotation | 6 | 2 |
| 9 to 10 | 4 | 2 | Shape, count, fill, rotation | 6 | 2 |
| 11 and up | 4 | 4 | Shape, count, fill, rotation | 6 | 2 |
A changing feature that is not a one of each rule is given the row rule or the column rule with equal chance. The step starts at the level saved for you and rises by one after every three grids. A round lasts 45 seconds.
Rotation only appears on arrows, wedges and triangles, because the other shapes look the same after a quarter turn.
From step 11 every feature follows the one of each rule, so the grid is four small Latin squares laid on top of each other. If you have played Mini Sudoku, the reasoning is the same as in its 4x4 rules: the gap takes the value its row and column are both missing.
Does every Missing Shape grid have exactly one answer?
Yes. We generated 78,000 grids, 6,000 at each step from 0 to 12, and ran each through a solver that tries every rule the generator can use on every feature. Each grid came back with one possible figure for the gap, and it matched the tile marked correct.
Does practice at matrix puzzles carry over to anything else?
People get faster and more accurate at matrix puzzles they practice, in part because the rule types repeat. Research has not established that this carries over to other kinds of thinking, and our article on brain training research goes through the evidence.
A Missing Shape score is a count of grids solved in 45 seconds. It is not a test result and says nothing about a person’s ability.
For other rule-finding games, Pattern Next asks for the sixth item in a row of five, Balance Scale has you compare three shapes by weight, and Card Sort changes its hidden rule without warning.
Common questions
How do you solve a 3 by 3 matrix puzzle?
Take one feature at a time, such as shape, number or shading. Work out the rule that feature follows along the rows and columns, apply each rule to the empty cell, and pick the option that fits every rule.
What are the common rules in matrix reasoning puzzles?
A feature can stay constant, step up or down in order, appear as three different values once each in every row, or come from adding or overlaying the first two figures in a row.
Where do matrix puzzles come from?
The best known set is Raven's Progressive Matrices, first published by John C. Raven in the United Kingdom in 1938. The standard form has 60 items in five sets of 12.
Does Missing Shape use addition or overlay rules?
No. Each feature in Missing Shape is either the same everywhere, the same along each row, the same down each column, or present once in every row and column.